Welcome to Fireside Cookies-coming soon!

A cottage cookie bakery making small batches of bake-to-order classic, specialty and unique truly homemade delicious and decadent cookies

Fireside Cookie Showcase

Featured Cookies for ~ Saturday December 14th, 2026 - Friday January 3rd, 2026

Fireside Cookie bakers will offer a showcase of classic favorites and uniquely crafted specialty cookies on a rotating basis. Please check here weekly for featured cookies.

The Classics

3.99 each

 

 Classic Oatmeal Raisin  

soft, chewy, fluffy, oatmeal cookies with plump raisins

Classic Peanut Butter

thick, slightly chewy, soft, powerfully peanutty

Scottish Shortbread

creamy, buttery, pure Scottish shortbread; flaky, melt-in-your-mouth, tender, delicate

~Original

~Orange-Chocolate Chip

~Iced Lemon

~Cranberry Orange

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Specialties & Unique

4.99 each

 

*Chocolate Cream Pie 

chocolatey, whipped cream and chocolate shavings; chocolate pie turned cookie

 *Coconut Cream Pie Cookies

toasted coconut, cream topping, all the makings of a pie-made to a cookie

Coffee Cake 

crumbly streusel topping, warm cinnamon, buttery, coffee cake turned cookie

The EPIC Chocolate Chip 

soft, chewy, fluffy, thick, gooey on the inside, golden brown and slightly crispy edges; literally EPIC

Seasonal & Holiday

4.99 each

 

*Frosted Pumpkin Caramel 

frosted, big, thick, chewy Fall in a cookie

Maple Brown Sugar 

crispy brown edges, chewy centers, buttery, pure Vermont maple syrup filled, topped with pure maple icing

*Cookies marked with an asterisk require refrigeration. 

“Fireside Cookies has the best cookies I have ever tasted! Each cookie is a special experience, delicious and so unique.  An outstanding and delicious cookie experience.”

[Robert, Lake Mary]